Homemade English Muffins

Homemade english muffins

I have a serious love affair with english muffins.  They are definitely one of my go-to breakfast options for during the week, especially when smeared with a little peanut or almond butter and a drizzle of honey.  You don’t even want to know how many I purchased each week at the food store … that is until now.

Homemade english muffins

I totally hated buying so many, but I could not find the right homemade recipe to replace my beloved english muffins from the store.  And boy did I try.  I went through a whole lotta recipes before I finally found the one.  Now don’t get me wrong, the others were fine (I mean let’s be honest, homemade bread of any kind is almost always a very very good thing).  But they weren’t quite right.

But this my friends is it.  These have both that wonderful homemade feel yet are still very close to the kind you can buy.  But better.  So much better.  And one of my favorite parts?  This recipe makes a LOT of english muffins.  So you don’t have to do all this work to wind up with only six.  Please, six english muffins do not last long in this house!  And if you don’t need that many, go ahead and freeze the rest.  So you can enjoy them at another time.  You’ll thank me later.

Homemade english muffins

Making these at home do take some time, but a lot of it is just waiting for the dough to rise and hanging out nearby while they cook.  And one taste of an egg and cheese sandwich using one of these bad boys?  Yeah, you’ll never go back to store-bought.

Homemade English Muffins
 
Yield: 16 to 17 english muffins
Ingredients
  • 1 ¾ cups lukewarm milk
  • 2 ¼ teaspoons (1 package) instant yeast
  • 3 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened
  • 1 ¼ teaspoons salt
  • 2 tablespoons granulated sugar
  • 1 large egg, lightly beaten
  • 4 ½ cups bread flour
  • cornmeal, for sprinkling the griddle/skillet
Instructions
  1. In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, add the milk. Sprinkle in the yeast and mix on low for a few seconds to combine. Add in the butter, salt, sugar, egg and flour. Start with the mixer on low (so the flour doesn’t go everywhere) and then increase the speed to medium. Continue to beat on medium for about 5 minutes - the dough with be smooth and satiny but still pretty soft (this dough is different from a lot of other yeasted breads, so be sure to use the paddle attachment the entire time).
  2. Using greased hands, form the dough into a rough ball and place in a large oiled bowl. Turn once to coat and then cover with a clean kitchen towel or plastic wrap. Let the dough rise until doubled in bulk, about 2 hours.
  3. Spray a griddle (or large skillet) with nonstick cooking spray then sprinkle very generously with cornmeal (I used both so I could cook all the english muffins at the same time).
  4. Gently deflate the dough then divide it into 16 to 17 equal sized pieces (using a kitchen scale mine were about 2 to 2 ¼ ounces each). Shape each piece into a smooth ball. Place the balls on the prepared cold griddle and then use your fingers to flatten each until they are about 3 to 3 ½ inches in diameter (they can be fairly close together on the griddle). *If you don’t have enough space on the griddle/skillet, you’ll need to cook in batches. Place the other balls (and then flatten them) on a baking sheet prepared the same way (so they can be transferred easily to the griddle later). Sprinkle the tops of all the english muffins with additional cornmeal. Cover the muffins with a clean kitchen towel or parchment paper and let them rest for 20 minutes.
  5. Turn the griddle or burner on low heat. Cook for about 12 to 15 minutes per side until golden brown and cooked through. When they are done, the inside of the muffins should be about 200 degrees using an instant-read thermometer. If the muffins start to brown too quickly (and are not cooked through), carefully transfer them to a baking sheet. Bake in a preheated 350 degree oven until done (another 5 to 10 minutes).
  6. Transfer the muffins to a wire rack to cool completely. Repeat the cooking process with the remaining muffins (if you are doing this in batches).
Notes
Use a fork to split the muffins (and not a knife) so that you get all the nooks and crannies.

Source:
Slightly adapted from King Arthur Flour.

 

More from Cookie Monster Cooking:

Comments

  1. Great recipe! I’m allergic to corn, and I was wondering if they could be cooked without the cornmeal or with some other substitute. What do you think?

  2. Michelle says:

    Have you ever made these with whole wheat bread flour or half and half?

    • Ashley @ Cookie Monster Cooking says:

      Not yet – it’s on my list of things I want to try (I prefer whole wheat breads over white)! I think you could definitely sub out a portion of the bread flour for whole wheat flour – I do that with a lot of recipes and don’t usually have a problem (some I’ll do half and half and sometimes I’ll do a third). Let me know if you try them that way!

  3. These are just gorgeous, Ashley! I’ve made English muffin BREAD, but not actual muffins. I need to though and yours are gorgeous. Pinned!

    • Ashley @ Cookie Monster Cooking says:

      Thanks Averie! Yes, you need to make english muffins! I’m obsessed with them now : )

  4. Aaa-maazing! I just made these and they turned out perfectly. I used both a skillet and a frying pan, and both turned out fine!

  5. Love English muffins! Yours came out so pretty: light and fluffy! Would love to try this recipe so I am pinning it!

  6. I’ve been dying to make my own english muffins! These look so good. I eat toasted english muffins all the time with peanut butter and jelly. :)

    • Ashley @ Cookie Monster Cooking says:

      You need to try making them! They’re sooo good. Especially with peanut butter and jelly : )

  7. I too am an English Muffin addict. I can’t wait to try your homemade version!! This could be life-changing!

  8. These look perfect, Ashley! English muffins are on my bucket list too.

  9. Ashley, true to form, you and I seem to be making the same things at the same time in our kitchens on opposite sides of the world! I just tried English muffins for the first time ever over the weekend. I loved them, but I’m thinking I might give this recipe a try – yours look spot on.

  10. Oh my gosh, yum in my tum!! There’s alot fewer ingredients than I expected, I think that makes up for having to wait around. These look fantastic, I wonder how they would freeze. You’ll have to let us know!

    • Ashley @ Cookie Monster Cooking says:

      They freeze well : ) I tested it with two … the others never made it to the freezer haha

  11. OMG I AM PINNING THIS IMMEDIATELY!! Every recipe I’ve seen for homemade English muffins seems so incredibly impossible, but this – this I could do! Ashley you are brilliant – they look just like store-bought but better :D

    • Ashley @ Cookie Monster Cooking says:

      You could definitely do this! It’s actually pretty simple – just lots of down time : )

  12. Mm, I’ve been seeing homemade english muffins everywhere lately. I think it’s a sign! Pinned :)

  13. Jennifer says:

    Those look delicious! Any chance I can convince you to come up with a great recipe for crumpets? (cousin to the English muffin and equally good at soaking up butter and jam!)

  14. I’m so going to make these, Ashley! I eat a whole grain English muffin a day at lunch time with peanut butter and banana. I buy a ton, also, and have many in the freezer for fear that I’ll run out! I’ve never experienced a homemade one, and yours look fantastic. If you say this is the one, then I believe you!

    • Ashley @ Cookie Monster Cooking says:

      haha I’m glad I’m not the only one who is crazy about english muffins. Yes, try them! I’m slightly obsessed : )

  15. I’m so glad you put this recipe up! I have two brothers who are both huge fans of English muffins. Luckily for us we have the best bakery in our local town that sells divine versions but I’ve always wanted to have a go at my own and this looks like a great recipe to start with! Xx

    • Ashley @ Cookie Monster Cooking says:

      I’m jealous of this bakery! haha There’s no really good ones close to us…. although maybe that’s for the best! I had a homemade english muffin while on vacation that prompted my search to re-create it at home : )

Speak Your Mind

*